GUIDE · ACCURACY

What to Do When AI Gets Your Insurance Brand Wrong

A practical workflow for capturing an incorrect AI claim about your brand, verifying it, fixing the sources you control and checking whether the error persists. It is the same process behind the initial accuracy review in every Brainpan.AI pilot.

1.WHY IT HAPPENS

The errors we see most often

The Q3 2026 accuracy study checked 1,065 claims AI engines made about insurers. Market-share claims were the least reliable (47.7% fully supported), mostly because engines repeated outdated rankings. Invented ratings and stale facts recurred across several engines. Most problems were not outright fabrications: they were partly right or out of date, which is why each claim needs to be classified, not just marked right or wrong.

2.THE WORKFLOW

Six steps from a wrong answer to a documented fix

1. Capture the claim and its context
Record the engine, the prompt, the date, the exact wording of the claim and any source the answer cited. Screenshots help, but keep the text: you will search for it later. Done when another person could reproduce the prompt.
2. Verify against an authoritative source
Check the claim against the source that actually governs it: your own policy documents and website, regulatory filings, or the published rating from the agency named. Done when the claim has a source on each side: what AI said and what the authority says.
3. Classify it
Use the categories from our research, supported, partly supported, outdated or contradicted, plus unresolved when no authoritative source settles it. Keep confirmed errors separate from statements you simply can’t verify.
4. Assign an owner
Each confirmed error gets one owner: web team, product, compliance, PR or your agency, depending on where the wrong information lives. Regulated statements go through your normal legal and compliance review.
5. Correct the sources you control, and request the rest
Update your website and structured data, business profiles and directory listings. Where a third-party page carries the wrong fact, request a correction from its publisher. Answers often repeat what these sources say.
6. Re-test and document
Once the corrected pages have had time to be recrawled, re-run the original prompt and a few variations on the same engines. Record whether the error still appears. Engines change on their own, so note the date and treat a fix that holds across repeat prompts as more meaningful than a single clean answer.
3.CLAIM LOG

An example claim log (illustrative)

Claim (as stated by AI)Authoritative source saysEngineClassOwnerStatus
“Not available in Oregon”Writes policies in Oregon since 2024 (company state list)Engine AOutdatedWeb teamState page updated; re-test in 30 days
“Rated A+ by a major rating agency”Current published rating is AEngine BContradictedPRRating page corrected; publisher contacted
“Offers a 25% multi-policy discount”Discount varies by state, up to 20%Engines A and CPartly supportedProduct + complianceDiscount page wording under review
“One of the five largest home insurers”No current ranking source confirms or rules outEngine CUnresolvedMarketingMonitor; no correction requested

Illustrative entries for a fictional insurer. Not findings about any real brand.

4.LIMITS

What this process can and can’t do

  • It can document errors, fix the record you control and show whether an error keeps recurring.
  • It can’t force an engine to change an answer, guarantee a timeline, or prove a correction caused a change.
  • It is factual verification, not a legal opinion or a compliance certification.

See also how to defend a brand against AI hallucinations and the Answer Accuracy definition.

Want this done for your brand?

Every pilot includes an initial accuracy review: claims about your brand checked against authoritative sources, with errors documented and important findings re-tested.

Included in a three-month pilot: from $3,500/month, $10,500 for Starter.
Kevin Walsh, Founder and Lead Engineer of Brainpan.AI

Written and reviewed by

Kevin Walsh

Kevin Walsh is the founder and lead engineer of Brainpan.AI, which builds the Visibility Engine, the measurement platform behind the AIVI™ benchmarks. Brainpan.AI independently measures how brands are mentioned, recommended, cited and described across AI answer engines.